Maltese Citizenship by Investment After the EU Court Ruling
Which approval matters for pending applications, what the ruling means if you already acquired Maltese citizenship, and what options new applicants can consider.

What to Check First
On April 29, 2025, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) held that Malta’s investor citizenship scheme, known as the Golden Passport, violated EU law. Malta’s July 2025 reform closed this route to new applications. CJEU, C‑181/23, operative part · Malta, L.N. 159/2025
Pending applications under Part IV of the 2020 program ceased to have effect unless the Minister had approved the naturalization before April 29, 2025. The CJEU ruling itself did not strip anyone of citizenship whose naturalization had already taken effect. Malta’s current citizenship by merit process involves a separate, case-by-case assessment. CJEU, C‑181/23, operative part · Malta, L.N. 159/2025, reg. 25
You are looking at Malta for the first time
Take the Golden Passport out of your plans. Check what residence rights are available where you actually intend to live.
Read the rulingYour application under the 2020 program was still pending
Establish whether and when the Minister approved naturalization under Part IV. Eligibility clearance and a residence permit serve different purposes.
Check the pending fileYour naturalization had already taken effect
Keep the naturalization certificate, date, and conditions for each person. Any official notice about an individual case needs its own review.
Check certificate and conditionsIn This Analysis
It’s Friday, just before the wire transfer.
A family has reserved an apartment in Sliema. Their daughter is due to start school in Malta in September. The deposit is due Monday.
Their adviser wrote that approval came through some time ago. The family wants to know whether they can sign. At that point, I would ask to see the official letter.
Who approved what, and when?
The answer determines whether the deposit secures a step toward a workable move or ties up money in an apartment the family may be unable to use as planned.
Whatever you sign in Malta should still make sense if the passport you’re hoping for falls through.
Malta’s Golden Passport and the EU Court’s Ruling
The CJEU ruled on April 29, 2025, in Case C‑181/23, Commission v. Malta. The case concerned the Maltese Citizenship by Naturalisation for Exceptional Services by Direct Investment program, which Malta had operated since 2020. Malta had set up a formal process linking naturalization to predetermined payments or investments. The Court found that the scheme breached Article 20 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union, which establishes EU citizenship, and Article 4(3) of the Treaty on European Union, which sets out the principle of sincere cooperation. Judgment, paras. 93–103, 121 and operative part
“the commercialisation of the granting of the status of national of a Member State and, by extension, Union citizenship”
Malta sets the conditions for its citizenship within the limits of EU law. Maltese citizenship also confers EU citizenship, whose rights can be exercised in other member states. The Court looked at what the old program’s screening was designed to establish. It looked for grounds to exclude applicants who were willing to pay. It offered no separate, affirmative basis for concluding that naturalization was warranted. Judgment, paras. 81–84, 101 and 111–116
Malta amended the Maltese Citizenship Act on July 24, 2025. Regulations published on July 29, 2025 removed the investor procedure and set out the transitional rules. If you have a Malta proposal in front of you today, ask three questions before paying the first fee. What status would you apply for, and under which current provision? Which authority decides? Who receives each payment, and what does it cover? A government fee and a private advisory fee each pay for something different. If the engagement still cites the former investor rules as the basis for a new application, withhold payment for that application. Act XXI of 2025 · L.N. 159/2025 · Community Malta Agency on the amendments
Pending Applications and the Approval Required Before April 29, 2025
Article 27(4) exempts naturalization applications previously filed under Article 10(9) from the legislative amendment, subject to the applicable regulations. Regulation 25 of Legal Notice 159 of 2025 generally preserves the earlier rules for acquiring citizenship through naturalization and for retaining or being deprived of citizenship acquired that way. It sets a precise cutoff for applications under Part IV of the former S.L. 188.06. An application ceased to have effect unless the Minister approved naturalization before April 29, 2025. An approval decision made on April 29 itself fell outside the cutoff. The 2026 amendments to the order establishing the Community Malta Agency likewise refer expressly to naturalization applications approved before that date. Maltese Citizenship Act, art. 27(4) · L.N. 159/2025, reg. 25 · L.N. 60/2026, reg. 5
Swipe to see the full table
| What you have in your file | What to confirm next |
|---|---|
| Payment receipts, a residence card, or acknowledgment of receipt | These documents show payment, residence status, or receipt, respectively. Look for the separate naturalization decision. |
| Eligibility clearance or permission to file the full application | Confirm whether the Minister later approved the naturalization application. These were separate steps under the former procedure. |
| Letter of Approval in Principle for the naturalization application | Check whether the letter communicates the Minister’s decision under Part IV, regulation 16, and establish when that decision was made. The letter may have been sent or received after the decision date. |
| Certificate of naturalization | Establish when naturalization took effect for the person named. A completed naturalization calls for a different review from a pending application. |
The wording Approval in Principle warrants close attention. Under the former Part IV procedure, that letter could communicate the Minister’s approval of the naturalization application itself. An intermediary’s email that simply says “approved” leaves the stage unclear. Check the file reference, legal basis, date of decision, people covered, and any conditions in the letter. If your case was under the older 2014 Individual Investor Programme, first establish which version of the law and which transitional rules apply. The court case and the cutoff discussed here concern the 2020 scheme. Former L.N. 437/2020, regs. 10, 15–17 and 31 · CJEU, para. 105
Two Files at the Cutoff
If the Minister actually approved the naturalization application under Part IV on April 28, 2025, and the letter was served in May, the earlier decision date can keep the application from lapsing under this rule.
If by April 28 only eligibility had been confirmed and the naturalization application was approved on April 29, the lapse rule applies.
Where two dates appear, obtain written confirmation of the actual date of the Minister’s decision. L.N. 159/2025, reg. 25 · Former L.N. 437/2020, reg. 16(6)–(7)
Even with timely approval, establish whether the applicant met all conditions and whether the case is pending, completed, or closed. The previous regulations allowed four months from the issuance of the approval letter to provide a certified copy of the sale or lease agreement and six months from approval to take the oath of allegiance. Ask Maltese counsel to obtain confirmation from the competent authority of the current status and any remaining deadlines. Consider any potential refund separately. The payee, purpose of payment, and terms of the agreement all matter. Former L.N. 437/2020, regs. 16(6)–(7) and 17
Back to the deposit in Sliema. The file contains a Letter of Approval in Principle for the father from April 2025. For the daughter, there is only an old residence card. Before Monday, the family needs two answers in writing. Who exactly did the earlier decision cover? On what basis can the daughter live in Malta when school starts? If she has a confirmed right to reside there by then regardless of the naturalization outcome, the family has a basis for the move. They should confirm her school admission separately. If the legal basis remains unclear, I would negotiate an extension to the reservation before the deposit is due.
What the Ruling Means If You Already Acquired Maltese Citizenship
The Court found that Malta had breached its treaty obligations. The operative part of the judgment orders no individual deprivation of citizenship. For a family, the review starts with when citizenship took effect. Article 12 of the Maltese Citizenship Act ties acquisition to the date of registration or naturalization. Keep the certificate, date, and conditions that applied at the time for each person. The date printed on a passport tells you when that document was issued. If there is a specific doubt about citizenship itself, the Minister may issue a certificate of citizenship on application under Article 20. CJEU, operative part · Maltese Citizenship Act, arts. 12 and 20
An earlier naturalization can be reviewed individually. Article 14 lists grounds including fraud, false representation, and concealment of material facts. Obligations under the rules in force at the time may also continue to apply to previous grants. The 2020 scheme provided for checks in the first five years, including review of continuing material obligations. Suppose the buyer of the property you used to qualify expects your signature on Thursday. First establish when your holding period started and whether you have already met the condition. That can determine whether the sale can go ahead now or whether the agreement needs a different deadline. Maltese Citizenship Act, arts. 14–15 · Former L.N. 437/2020, regs. 16(7), 18 and 24
If you receive a notice of proposed deprivation, keep the notice and proof of service that same day and send both to Maltese counsel immediately. If the person is in Malta when served, the regulations generally allow 21 days from service to submit a written request for an inquiry. Otherwise, the Minister sets a period of at least 21 days. The notice must state the deadline. If loss of Maltese citizenship would also mean loss of EU citizenship, CJEU case law requires an assessment of proportionality under EU law. Citizenship Regulations, reg. 5 · CJEU, Rottmann, C‑135/08, paras. 55–59
How Malta Assesses Citizenship by Merit Today
Article 10(9) allows discretionary naturalization for exceptional services or contributions to Malta or humanity. The law expressly includes job creation. Naturalization may also be considered where it is of exceptional interest to Malta, for example if a person’s profile or expertise would significantly advance the national interest. Entrepreneurs, scientists, and artists may fall within these provisions. The contribution itself matters, and the law leaves the individual decision to the Minister. Maltese Citizenship Act, art. 10(9)
“Decisions on the granting of citizenship by merit are discretionary”
The process has two distinct steps. A proposal explaining the grounds for the request first goes through the Community Malta Agency to the evaluation board. Once the board reviews the proposal and makes a recommendation, the Minister decides whether to approve the proposal in principle. The applicant can then file a formal naturalization application. The letter may again be called a Letter of Approval in Principle. At the relevant stage under the former program, that title communicated the Minister’s approval of the naturalization application itself. Under the current merit process, it initially concerns the proposal. For the application that follows, the regulations require evidence of at least eight months of residence in Malta before the formal application, adequate knowledge of Maltese or English, and evidence of the connections described in the proposal, among other requirements. Some applicants must also show a right to suitable accommodation. The authorities may charge administrative fees. Eight months is a minimum residence evidence requirement. The timing of the naturalization decision is separate. The final decision remains with the Minister. S.L. 188.06, regs. 11A–11B
An entrepreneur wants to build a team in Malta. On Tuesday, he is due to approve three employment contracts, committing payroll for the coming year. I would ask to see the signed customer contract, the funding, and the name of the person who will lead the team. If the contract can support the team even if naturalization is denied, he can make the hiring decision on business grounds. If the budget depends on getting a passport, he holds off on the offers. A claim of exceptional contribution requires evidence of a different kind. What work and jobs can he already document? What work and jobs are planned, funded, and scheduled? Who could independently confirm the results? S.L. 188.06, regs. 11A(1) and 11B(1) · NBF analysis on the first contract for a Maltese limited company
When the Malta Golden Visa Fits a Residence Plan
If you plan to live in Malta, start with your citizenship. German nationals and other EU citizens can exercise their EU free movement rights. According to Identità, EU citizens staying in Malta for more than three months must register their residence and meet the requirements for the applicable category. For family members from outside the EU, relevant factors include the family relationship, the EU citizen’s exercise of free movement rights, and the family member’s own evidence. Before moving, establish what each person needs to do to secure residence. Identità, EU citizen registration · Identità, family members

The Malta Permanent Residence Programme (MPRP), often searched for as the Malta Golden Visa, is for eligible nationals of countries outside the EU, the European Economic Area, and Switzerland. A successful application grants permanent residence in Malta and generally allows short stays in the Schengen Area of up to 90 days in any 180-day period. The laws of the destination country govern a permanent move or taking up work there. Check access to employment in Malta separately as well. Residency Malta Agency, MPRP · Residency Malta Agency, MPRP FAQ on work authorization
Another family from outside the EU is looking for an apartment in Sliema. The parents can see themselves making it their home. Their son has an apprenticeship in Munich and is due to start in September. The MPRP may be a good fit for the parents’ residence plans. For their son, accepting the apprenticeship depends on securing the right status in Germany in time. Check that deadline before the family signs a lease for everyone or he commits to the apprenticeship. A workable Malta plan may call for two different residence decisions within the same family. NBF guide to the Malta Permanent Residence Programme
Depending on the person’s circumstances, Maltese citizenship may be available under other legal provisions, including citizenship by descent or ordinary naturalization. Article 10(1) generally requires twelve months of continuous residence immediately before filing and at least four additional years of residence in total during the six years preceding that twelve-month period, among other conditions. This provides a framework for assessing actual residence. Buying property, holding MPRP status, or reaching a particular anniversary does not on its own confer an entitlement. Maltese Citizenship Act, arts. 5 and 10(1)
What to Document Before Your Next Payment or Signature
Start by writing down the next step that will cost money or set a deadline. It might be a security deposit, the start of the school year, the expiration of a residence permit, or a statement to a bank. Next to it, write the name of the person whose status needs to be documented by that date. This can expose a gap, for example if you were counting on a parent’s letter to prove a son’s status, or on a Maltese residence card to allow work in another country.
Swipe to see the full table
| Before you commit | What belongs in your file |
|---|---|
| Release funds for a pending application under the old program or a related project | Date and contents of the Minister’s decision, current status with the authority, outstanding conditions, and contractual consequences of a further payment. |
| Commit to housing, school, or a start date for work | The specific right for each person and destination country, its validity on the date needed, and a realistic alternative date or independent residence route. |
| Confirm passport status to a bank or business partner | Proof of effective acquisition of citizenship for the person in question and, where relevant, the official document addressing any discrepancy and the authority to contact. |
| End an arrangement tied to an existing condition or respond to a proposed deprivation notice | The applicable version of the law, the original condition, date of service, and a written assessment from Maltese counsel. |
A family office is asked to confirm by Tuesday which status a bank can rely on in its account-opening review. The father has a certificate of naturalization. For his adult child, there is only a forwarded email. Confirm what the certificate establishes for the father. Explicitly leave the child’s status unconfirmed until the competent authority or Maltese counsel verifies the evidence. The bank can assess the documented facts without putting your client in a position where they have to correct a statement that should never have been made.
On Monday, the family in Sliema can use the confirmed right of residence to decide whether to pay the deposit. While the daughter’s status is still unconfirmed, they can keep the reservation if the landlord extends it. That preserves a choice about when to move and when she starts school.
Frequently Asked Questions About Malta’s Golden Passport
Can you still buy a Maltese passport?
Malta’s former citizenship by investment program is closed to new applications. The often-cited €600,000 or €750,000 were historical government contributions under the 2020 program. Property and donation requirements applied in addition. If you are reviewing an old invoice, use this distinction to examine the government contribution, payments to a service provider, and other amounts separately. Today’s citizenship by merit process involves an individual, discretionary decision. CJEU, C‑181/23, para. 102 · Community Malta Agency, Citizenship by Merit
What happens to an application filed before the EU Court ruling?
For applications under the former Part IV, what matters is whether the Minister approved naturalization before April 29, 2025. The earlier filing date alone is insufficient. If approval was timely, establish separately whether the applicant met the former conditions and confirm the current status of the file. L.N. 159/2025, reg. 25
Does my old residence card remain valid if the earlier application lapsed?
The cutoff governs the naturalization application. For residence, check the legal basis, expiry date, and current status of the residence permit itself. Have that status confirmed before planning a move or return trip using the card. L.N. 159/2025, reg. 25 · Identità, legal basis and scope of residence
Does my existing Maltese passport remain valid?
The CJEU judgment itself neither deprived individuals of Maltese citizenship nor invalidated their passports as a group. If there is a specific concern, establish whether citizenship still stands and whether the travel document is valid as separate questions. If you receive a notice of proposed deprivation, responding by the deadline is the immediate priority. CJEU, operative part · Maltese Citizenship Act, arts. 14–15 and 20
Does the Malta Golden Visa lead to citizenship?
A successful MPRP application grants permanent residence in Malta. Anyone considering naturalization later must meet the conditions of the separate legal provision under which they apply. Residency Malta Agency, MPRP · Maltese Citizenship Act, art. 10
Sources and Further Reading
- CJEU, C‑181/23, operative part
- Malta, L.N. 159/2025
- Act XXI of 2025
- Community Malta Agency on the amendments
- Maltese Citizenship Act, art. 27(4)
- L.N. 60/2026, reg. 5
- Former L.N. 437/2020, regs. 10, 15–17 and 31
- Citizenship Regulations, reg. 5
- CJEU, Rottmann, C‑135/08, paras. 55–59
- Official statement
- S.L. 188.06, regs. 11A–11B
- Identità, EU citizen registration
- Identità, family members
- Residency Malta Agency, MPRP
- Residency Malta Agency, MPRP FAQ on work authorization
- Identità, legal basis and scope of residence
Share This Analysis
Save or Print This Analysis
Where to Go From Here
Follow Alexander Erber
Strategic Initial Briefing
What commitment does your family need to be able to make next? We assess how your residence, mobility, or family plans depend on the documents you have.
Preparation
Bring the deadline, the people involved, and a list of the documents you have.
60 minutes with Alexander Erber
Identify what your next commitment depends on and which question needs an answer first.
Short written briefing
Receive a prioritized set of questions and a sequence for the next steps.
When needed, we coordinate the handoff to qualified advisers in Malta or elsewhere. Those advisers are responsible for the legal assessment of any individual application and its deadlines.
If you are bringing a case as a law firm or family office, you can start with an anonymized summary.


